BattleHome

Real vs Artificial Christmas Tree: Which Should You Get?

A fresh-cut tree or one from a box in the basement? Each has real trade-offs in cost, upkeep, safety and environmental impact. The facts below come from tree growers' associations and fire safety guidance. Pick the one you would put up this year.

A community battle on FindBest — tap a side to vote; switch any time. The bar is the live split of votes.

50%50%
Side A

Real Christmas tree

A fresh-cut tree typically grows on a farm for around seven years before it is sold, according to the National Christmas Tree Association. Fir and pine give the smell people remember. It needs water every day, and fire safety guidance says to remove it once it is dry. After the season many cities collect trees and chip them into mulch.

Pros
  • + Real smell and look
  • + Can be chipped or composted after the season
  • + Supports local tree farms
Cons
  • − Has to be watered every day
  • − Dry trees are a fire risk
  • − Needles to clean up
Side B

Artificial Christmas tree

Bought once and reused each year, often with lights already strung. Fire safety guidance says to choose one labelled fire resistant. Most are made from PVC plastic and cannot be recycled at the end of their life, so the environmental case depends on keeping one for many years. It needs storage space for the rest of the year.

Pros
  • + No watering or needles
  • + Reusable for many years
  • + Pre-lit options save setup time
Cons
  • − Usually PVC, hard to recycle
  • − No real tree smell
  • − Needs storage space

Comments