BattleSports

Lemieux vs Gretzky: Who Was the More Talented Player?

Mario Lemieux against Wayne Gretzky, the two great centres of the 1980s and 1990s. Gretzky owns the records; Lemieux scored at almost the same rate per game while fighting cancer and a bad back. This battle asks a narrower question than 'who was better': who had more pure talent? Facts from hockey-reference and the Hockey Hall of Fame.

A community battle on FindBest — tap a side to vote; switch any time. The bar is the live split of votes.

50%50%
Side A

Mario Lemieux

Scored 690 goals and 1,723 points in only 915 NHL games for Pittsburgh. Won the Stanley Cup and the Conn Smythe in 1991 and 1992, the Hart Trophy three times and the Art Ross six times. In 1992-93 he was treated for Hodgkin's lymphoma mid-season and still won the scoring title with 160 points in 60 games. He retired in 1997, then came back in December 2000 as the team's owner.

Pros
  • + About 1.88 points per game for his career
  • + Two Cups and two Conn Smythes
  • + Won a scoring title the season he had cancer treatment
  • + Six Art Ross Trophies
Cons
  • − Missed hundreds of games to back problems and illness
  • − Totals far below Gretzky's
Side B

Wayne Gretzky

The NHL's all-time leader in assists (1,963) and points (2,857), scored over 1,487 games. Won four Stanley Cups with Edmonton, nine Hart Trophies and ten Art Ross Trophies. His 163 assists in 1985-86 are still the single-season record, and his 50 goals in 39 games in 1981-82 is still the fastest 50 ever.

Pros
  • + NHL records for career assists and points
  • + Four Stanley Cups
  • + Ten Art Ross Trophies
  • + Stayed healthy and productive for two decades
Cons
  • − Surrounded by Hall of Fame teammates in Edmonton
  • − Played in the NHL's highest-scoring era

Comments