BattleSports

McDavid vs Gretzky: Who's the Greatest Oiler?

Connor McDavid against Wayne Gretzky, the two best players ever to wear an Edmonton Oilers sweater. Gretzky has the rings and records nobody has touched; McDavid has the most dominant scoring of the modern, low-scoring era. The facts on each side are below, taken from hockey-reference and NHL.com. Pick the one you would build an Oilers team around.

A community battle on FindBest — tap a side to vote; switch any time. The bar is the live split of votes.

50%50%
Side A

Connor McDavid

Drafted first overall by Edmonton in 2015. Won the Hart Trophy in 2017, 2021 and 2023 and the Art Ross in 2017, 2018, 2021, 2022 and 2023. His 153 points in 2022-23 were the most in a season since 1995-96. He won the 2024 Conn Smythe as playoff MVP even though Edmonton lost the Final, and scored the overtime winner for Canada in the 2025 4 Nations Face-Off final.

Pros
  • + Most dominant scorer of the modern low-scoring era
  • + 153-point season in 2022-23
  • + Conn Smythe Trophy in 2024
  • + Skating speed nobody in the league matches
Cons
  • − Lost the Stanley Cup Final to Florida in 2024 and 2025
  • − Career totals are a fraction of Gretzky's so far
Side B

Wayne Gretzky

Won four Stanley Cups with Edmonton (1984, 1985, 1987, 1988) before the August 1988 trade to Los Angeles. Finished his career with 894 goals, 1,963 assists and 2,857 points, the all-time NHL points record. Won nine Hart Trophies and ten Art Ross Trophies, scored 92 goals in 1981-82 and put up 215 points in 1985-86, both still single-season records.

Pros
  • + Four Stanley Cups as an Oiler
  • + 2,857 career points, the NHL record
  • + Nine Hart Trophies
  • + Single-season records for goals (92) and points (215)
Cons
  • − Played in the highest-scoring era in NHL history
  • − Spent the second half of his career away from Edmonton

Comments