Patrick Roy vs Martin Brodeur: Who's the Greatest Goalie?
The two Quebec-born goalies who own the record book. Brodeur has the most wins and shutouts in NHL history; Roy has the most Conn Smythe Trophies and four Cups with two teams. Which one would you want in net for a Game 7? Facts from hockey-reference.
A community battle on FindBest — tap a side to vote; switch any time. The bar is the live split of votes.
Patrick Roy
Won four Stanley Cups: 1986 and 1993 with Montreal, 1996 and 2001 with Colorado. His three Conn Smythe Trophies (1986, 1993, 2001) are the most of any player. Finished with 551 regular-season wins and won the Vezina three times. Montreal traded him to Colorado in December 1995, and he won the Cup there that same season.
- + Record three Conn Smythe Trophies
- + Four Cups with two different teams
- + Popularised the butterfly style
- − Fewer career wins and shutouts than Brodeur
- − His Montreal exit was a public blow-up
Martin Brodeur
Holds the NHL records for regular-season wins (691) and shutouts (125). Won three Stanley Cups with New Jersey, in 1995, 2000 and 2003, four Vezina Trophies, and Olympic gold with Canada in 2002 and 2010. His puck handling was so effective that the NHL added the trapezoid behind the net in 2005 to limit where goalies could play the puck.
- + NHL record 691 wins
- + NHL record 125 shutouts
- + Three Stanley Cups
- + Changed the rules with his puck handling
- − Never won a Conn Smythe
- − Played behind New Jersey's defensive system
Comments
Related lists· more in Sports
- McDavid vs Gretzky: Who's the Greatest Oiler?Battle · Sports · 2 entries · FindBest Editors
- Crosby vs Ovechkin: Who Had the Better Career?Battle · Sports · 2 entries · FindBest Editors
- Oilers vs Flames: Who Wins the Battle of Alberta?Battle · Sports · 2 entries · FindBest Editors
- Maple Leafs vs Canadiens: Which Original Six Team Is Better?Battle · Sports · 2 entries · FindBest Editors
- Brady vs Mahomes: Who's the Greater Quarterback?Battle · Sports · 2 entries · FindBest Editors
- Jordan vs LeBron: Who's the NBA GOAT?Battle · Sports · 2 entries · FindBest Editors