BattleSports

McDavid vs Crosby: Who's the Better Captain?

Two first-overall picks, two franchise captains, two of the best centres in NHL history. Crosby has won everything; McDavid has the bigger numbers but is still chasing a Cup. This battle asks who you would rather have wearing the C for a playoff run. Facts from hockey-reference and NHL.com.

A community battle on FindBest — tap a side to vote; switch any time. The bar is the live split of votes.

50%50%
Side A

Connor McDavid

Named Edmonton's captain in October 2016, at 19, the youngest captain in NHL history at the time. Has led the Oilers to the Stanley Cup Final in 2024 and 2025, losing both to Florida, and won the 2024 Conn Smythe. Three Hart Trophies (2017, 2021, 2023) and five Art Ross Trophies by 2023.

Pros
  • + Three Hart Trophies
  • + Conn Smythe in 2024
  • + Took the Oilers to two straight Finals
Cons
  • − No Stanley Cup as captain through 2025
  • − Lost both Finals to the same team
Side B

Sidney Crosby

Became Pittsburgh's captain in 2007 and lifted the Stanley Cup in 2009 at 21, the youngest captain to win it. Added Cups in 2016 and 2017 with the Conn Smythe both years. Captained Canada to Olympic gold in Sochi in 2014 and won the Hart Trophy in 2007 and 2014.

Pros
  • + Three Stanley Cups as captain
  • + Two Conn Smythe Trophies
  • + Captained Canada to Olympic gold
Cons
  • − Fewer individual scoring titles than McDavid
  • − Pittsburgh missed the playoffs in his later seasons

Comments