BattleMovies

It's a Wonderful Life vs Miracle on 34th Street: Best Classic Christmas Film?

The two black-and-white Christmas classics from the 1940s. It's a Wonderful Life was a box office disappointment that became a TV tradition; Miracle on 34th Street won three Oscars. Which classic do you watch every year? Facts from the films' records.

A community battle on FindBest — tap a side to vote; switch any time. The bar is the live split of votes.

50%50%
Side A

It's a Wonderful Life (1946)

Directed by Frank Capra, with James Stewart as George Bailey and Donna Reed as Mary. It received five Academy Award nominations, including Best Picture, but won none, and it lost money in theatres. It found its audience on television in the 1970s and 80s, when it aired constantly after its copyright was not renewed. The American Film Institute ranked it the most inspiring American film.

Pros
  • + James Stewart's best performance
  • + Ranked No. 1 on AFI's most inspiring films
  • + Ending still works
Cons
  • − Dark for long stretches
  • − Long at over two hours
Side B

Miracle on 34th Street (1947)

Edmund Gwenn plays Kris Kringle, a Macy's Santa who says he is the real one and ends up in court. Gwenn won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor, and the film also won for its story and screenplay. Its opening was filmed at the real 1946 Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade. A young Natalie Wood co-stars.

Pros
  • + Three Academy Awards
  • + Lighter and shorter than It's a Wonderful Life
  • + Filmed at the real Macy's parade
Cons
  • − Less emotional weight
  • − The 1994 remake causes confusion

Comments