Home Alone vs Elf: Which Is the Better Christmas Movie?
Two Christmas comedies that get rewatched every December. Home Alone is the 1990 slapstick classic; Elf is the 2003 Will Ferrell film that became a modern staple. Which one goes on first this year? Release and box office facts from Box Office Mojo.
A community battle on FindBest — tap a side to vote; switch any time. The bar is the live split of votes.
Home Alone (1990)
Directed by Chris Columbus and written and produced by John Hughes. Macaulay Culkin plays Kevin McCallister, eight years old and left behind when his family flies to Paris, who defends the house from two burglars with homemade traps. Earned about $285 million in North America, one of the biggest box office hits of its era. The house is in Winnetka, Illinois.
- + Iconic traps and slapstick
- + John Williams score
- + Works for every age
- − The violence is more cartoonish than some parents expect
- − The sequel copies the formula almost exactly
Elf (2003)
Directed by Jon Favreau. Will Ferrell plays Buddy, a human raised by elves at the North Pole, who goes to New York to find his father, played by James Caan. Zooey Deschanel co-stars. Earned about $173 million in North America and was later adapted into a Broadway musical.
- + Will Ferrell's best family performance
- + Sweet without being sappy
- + Very quotable
- − The humour relies on one joke for some viewers
- − Less of a classic for older audiences
Comments
Related lists· more in Movies
- Die Hard vs Love Actually: Which Is the Better Christmas Movie?Battle · Movies · 2 entries · FindBest Editors
- Best Beginner-Friendly Ski Hills Near Calgary (2026-27 Season)Ranked · Outdoor · 6 entries · FindBest Editors
- Best Holiday Light Displays in and Around Calgary (2026)Ranked · Events · 6 entries · FindBest Editors
- The Best Websites for Fact-Checking Conspiracy Theories and Viral ClaimsRanked · Education · 10 entries · FindBest Editors
- The Best Websites for Unsolved Mysteries, Cold Cases and Declassified FilesRanked · Hobbies · 10 entries · FindBest Editors
- McDavid vs Gretzky: Who's the Greatest Oiler?Battle · Sports · 2 entries · FindBest Editors